Naturally Aspirated Engines: Why Enthusiasts Want Them

Naturally Aspirated Engines: Why Enthusiasts Want Them

Sound, throttle response and reliability. What sets naturally aspirated engines apart from turbos, and why they're disappearing from new cars.

There are fewer naturally aspirated engines on sale every year. Almost everything is now turbocharged or hybrid, and even the last holdouts are under threat. Andreas Preuninger, head of Porsche's GT division, has admitted that meeting Euro 7 without turbos or electrification probably won't be possible. That could affect even the naturally aspirated 911 GT3.

Yet among enthusiasts, interest keeps growing. Hagerty put the V10-powered BMW M5 E60 on its list of cars to watch for 2026 precisely because BMW no longer builds naturally aspirated M engines. So why are they so loved?

What naturally aspirated actually means

A naturally aspirated engine draws in air on its own, with no turbocharger or supercharger. There are only two ways to get more power out of it: more displacement or more revs.

That's why the best-known naturally aspirated engines either have lots of cylinders or rev past 8,000 rpm. The power doesn't come to you; you have to chase it up the rev range. And that's exactly what makes them special.

Why they sound better

Every time a cylinder fires, it sends a pressure pulse into the exhaust. The more cylinders and the higher the revs, the faster those pulses follow one another, and the higher and cleaner the sound.

On a turbocharged engine, the turbine sits right in the exhaust. The pulses have to pass through it, which smooths them out and muffles them. The result is quieter and less distinctive. That's also why so many modern turbo cars rely on exhaust valves or sound piped through the speakers.

A naturally aspirated engine has nothing like that in the way, so the sound comes out exactly as the engine makes it.

Throttle response

A turbo needs a moment for the exhaust gases to spin it up. That's turbo lag. Modern turbos are very quick, but they can't eliminate it entirely.

Porsche's new 911 GTS with T-Hybrid shows how far manufacturers will go to fight it. Its turbo has its own electric motor that spins it up instantly, regardless of engine speed, so lag all but disappears. When there's surplus exhaust energy, the same motor works in reverse as a generator. That electricity goes to a small battery or to a second electric motor in the gearbox, which adds torque right from idle. In other words, Porsche uses electricity to recreate what a naturally aspirated engine always had.

But a naturally aspirated engine always responds instantly. Press the throttle and it pulls right away, with power building evenly all the way to the redline. A turbo engine usually delivers its peak torque low in the rev range and then holds it flat. It's fast and effortless, but less exciting.

What about superchargers?

A supercharger also forces more air into the engine, but it's driven by a belt from the engine rather than by exhaust gas. Boost is there immediately, with no waiting, and the exhaust stays unobstructed. You also get the signature supercharger whine.

The downside is fuel consumption, since the engine has to power the supercharger itself. That's why manufacturers gradually switched to turbos. Still, if you want lots of power with instant response, cars like the Mercedes E55 AMG Kompressor or Audis with the supercharged 3.0-liter V6 are an interesting alternative.

And reliability?

A naturally aspirated engine has no turbo, intercooler or extra complications, so there's less to go wrong. It also runs at lower pressures and temperatures.

That doesn't make it automatically more reliable, though. Today's turbo engines are designed for boost from the start, and much of the turbo's bad reputation comes from the past. Naturally aspirated engines have their own weak spots too: BMW's V8 and V10 engines from 2005 to 2013 are known for rod bearing wear. The ones with a reputation for being truly durable tend to be relaxed, large-displacement engines, like the 5.0-liter V8 in the Mercedes SL500, a car we bought for multiple clients this year.

Three cars that show what it's all about

A naturally aspirated engine offers an experience a turbo can't quite replicate. That's why cars from the last years of the naturally aspirated era are in such demand today.

The BMW M3 E92 (2007–2013) uses a 4.0-liter V8 derived directly from the V10 in the BMW M5 E60. It shares the same design and cylinder dimensions, just with two fewer cylinders. It revs to 8,400 rpm and remains the only production M3 generation with a V8.

The first-generation Audi RS5 (2010–2015) is powered by a 4.2-liter V8 making 450 PS at 8,250 rpm. PistonHeads calls it one of the last non-turbo V8s, and one that needs to be revved. Where the M3 is sharper, the RS5 is more of a fast grand tourer with quattro all-wheel drive. Its 2017 successor switched to a turbocharged V6.

The Porsche Cayman 981 (2013–2016) is the last Cayman with a naturally aspirated flat-six in every version. When its major facelift, the 718, arrived in 2016, the core models switched to turbocharged four-cylinders. The naturally aspirated six only returned later, in the pricier GT4, Spyder and GTS 4.0.

Ultimately, the value of any specific car comes down to its history and condition. If you're considering one of these, we'd be glad to help you find the right one.

Stay informed

Receive RENNscout market insights, buying guidance, and selected enthusiast-car stories.

Naturally Aspirated Engines: Why Enthusiasts Want Them